Short-Term vs Long-Term Rental: Which Makes More Money?
STRs can absolutely generate higher gross income than long-term rentals on the same property. They can also generate significantly lower net income once you account for costs, seasonality, and management intensity. Whether STR or LTR wins comes down to one thing: a complete, side-by-side comparison of net income after every relevant expense.
11 min read
Updated June 2025
Informational only — not financial or investment advice
12-month lease. Fixed monthly income. Tenant pays utilities. Simpler management.
Why Gross Revenue Comparisons Are Misleading
Most STR-vs-LTR conversations start and end with gross revenue. AirDNA, Mashvisor, and Airbnb's own estimator tools give you a before-expenses number instantly. Long-term rent is equally visible on Zillow or Rentometer. The problem is that gross revenue comparisons ignore the structural cost differences between the two models — and those differences are substantial.
A property earning $3,500/month gross on Airbnb at 70% occupancy, after platform fees, cleaning fees, utilities, furnishing, and management, might net $1,800/month. The same property long-term at $1,750/month might net $1,400/month. The STR still wins — but the margin is $400/month, not $1,750/month. And it comes with considerably more operational complexity.
Run the net numbers. Always.
Building the Long-Term Rental (LTR) Baseline
Start with the simpler model and establish your LTR net income first. This becomes the floor against which STR performance is measured. Working example: 3-bedroom single-family home, current market value $320,000.
STR revenue depends on two variables: nightly rate and occupancy. Both require market research, not guesswork. Pull data from AirDNA or Mashvisor for your specific market and property type. Look at comparable active listings and check their calendars for actual booking density. Account for seasonality.
For this same property in a mid-size market with moderate STR demand:
Average nightly rate: $145
Realistic occupancy: 68% (20.4 nights/month avg)
Gross monthly revenue: $145 × 20.4 = $2,958/month
That's $1,058/month more in gross revenue than the LTR baseline. Now build the expense side — this is where STR economics diverge sharply from LTR assumptions.
STR Operating Expenses: The Full Picture
Every cost category in the STR model either increases versus LTR or has no LTR equivalent. Here's what it actually costs to run a 3-bedroom STR property:
VRBO charges 5% on most host-fee structures. Multi-platform channel managers add further fees. No LTR equivalent.
🧹
Cleaning Costs (~7 cleans/month × $140)
− $980/month
The number that shocks most investors running STR math for the first time. STRs require professional cleaning between every guest. This single line item is the primary reason high-occupancy STRs frequently fail to outperform LTR on a net basis.
🛋️
Furnishing & Supplies (amortized)
− $325/month
Initial furnishing for a 3-bed property: $8,000–$18,000. Amortized over 5 years plus ongoing consumable restocking. No LTR equivalent — long-term tenants furnish their own units.
⚡
Utilities (electricity, gas, water, internet)
− $350/month
Long-term tenants pay their own utilities in most markets. STR hosts pay everything — plus streaming services guests expect. This is a structural cost difference, not a management choice.
👔
STR Property Management (25% of gross)
− $740/month
Full-service STR management runs 20–30% vs. 10% for LTR. Reflects guest communication, check-in coordination, cleaning oversight, and dynamic pricing. Self-managers save this — but should account for 10–15 hours/month of active work.
🛡️
STR-Specific Insurance
− $185/month
Standard landlord policies typically exclude or severely limit short-term rental activity. Dedicated STR or commercial hospitality policies run $150–$250/month depending on property and location.
🏛️
Property Taxes
− $290/month
Same as LTR in most jurisdictions — though some municipalities are beginning to apply different tax treatment to STRs. Always check local rules before committing to the strategy.
🔧
Maintenance (1.5% of value/yr — higher than LTR)
− $400/month
STR properties experience faster wear and tear. Guest traffic is higher, turnover more frequent, and hotel-quality expectations mean faster replacement cycles. Budget 1.5% vs. the standard 1% for LTR.
Side-by-Side NOI: The Full Comparison
📊 STR vs LTR — Monthly Net Operating Income
🏖️ Short-Term Rental
🏡 Long-Term Rental
Gross Revenue$2,958
Gross Rent$1,900
Platform fees− $89
Vacancy (6%)− $114
Cleaning costs− $980
Taxes− $290
Furnishing/supplies− $325
Insurance− $120
Utilities− $350
Management (10%)− $179
STR management (25%)− $740
Maintenance (1%)− $267
STR insurance− $185
CapEx reserve (1%)− $267
Taxes + maintenance (1.5%)− $690
Monthly STR NOI− $401
Monthly LTR NOI$663
📊 Net Result: LTR Wins in This Scenario
LTR outperforms STR by
$1,064/month
On a net operating basis. The STR generated $1,058 more in gross revenue — but $2,122 more in operating costs. This is the outcome when every expense category is counted honestly. The STR model does not automatically win just because gross revenue is higher.
Why the STR Math Broke — and When It Doesn't
This outcome surprises many investors, but it illustrates a repeating pattern: management costs and cleaning fees alone can consume 35–45% of gross STR revenue. Add utilities, insurance, and higher maintenance, and the expense load is fundamentally different. The STR model produces better net income under specific conditions:
💎
Higher Nightly Rates
At $225/night with 68% occupancy, monthly gross jumps to $4,590 — changing the math significantly even with the same expense structure. Tourist markets and premium properties can clear this bar.
⏰
Self-Management Execution
Eliminating the 25% management fee saves $740/month in this example. Investors who build systems for guest communication, pricing, and cleaning oversight can capture this margin — if they actually have the time.
🗺️
Genuine STR Demand Markets
Not every market supports 68%+ occupancy. At 45% occupancy and $145/night, gross drops to $1,958/month — below LTR gross rent. The entire STR premise collapses without real underlying demand.
🌙
Longer Average Stay Length
Minimum stay policies of 5–7 nights cut cleaning costs per month dramatically. A property with 4 cleans/month instead of 7 saves $420 in cleaning alone — often the difference between positive and negative STR NOI.
The Risk Profile Difference Nobody Talks About Enough
Net income is one dimension of this comparison. Risk is another — and the two strategies carry meaningfully different profiles.
🏖️ STR Risk Factors
Seasonal revenue volatility — some months earn 3× others
Platform algorithm and policy changes that suppress listings overnight
Local regulation changes — many US cities have restricted or banned STRs in the last 3 years
Higher operating cost base amplifies losses during slow periods
Guest damage, neighbor complaints, HOA restrictions
Requires active management, contingency reserves, and regulatory monitoring
🏡 LTR Risk Factors
Tenant non-payment or damage
Extended vacancy between tenants (typically 2–4 weeks)
Rent growth limited by market and lease terms
Eviction costs and timelines if tenant stops paying
Using the example above: LTR rent = $1,900/month. You need gross STR revenue above $3,800/month to clear this threshold — which accounts for the structurally higher cost base of the STR model.
If local STR data suggests $2,800–$3,200/month gross → LTR probably wins on a net basis.
If local STR data suggests $4,500+/month gross → the STR premium likely justifies the model even after all expenses.
This isn't a replacement for full analysis — it's a filter to avoid spending time modeling a comparison where the answer is predetermined by the revenue gap.
It depends entirely on the market, property type, occupancy rate, and expense management. In high-demand tourist markets with strong nightly rates and efficient operations, STR can generate 30–60% more net income than LTR. In average markets with realistic expense loads, LTR frequently outperforms STR on a net basis despite lower gross revenue. The comparison must be made on net income, not gross.
What occupancy rate does an STR need to beat long-term rental income?
The break-even occupancy varies by market and expense structure, but most STR properties need to sustain 65–75% annual occupancy at market nightly rates to generate equivalent net income to a long-term rental. Below that threshold, the higher cost base of the STR model typically gives LTR the advantage. This is why researching realistic occupancy — not the optimistic platform estimates — is critical before committing to the STR model.
What are the biggest hidden costs of running a short-term rental?
Cleaning fees are consistently the most underestimated cost — particularly for properties with short average stays. A 3-bedroom property with 2–3 night average stays might require 7+ professional cleans per month, consuming nearly $1,000. Utilities, furnishing replacement cycles, and STR-specific insurance also catch new operators off guard. Many investors initially model STR expenses using LTR assumptions, which materially overstates net income.
How does local regulation affect the STR vs. LTR decision?
Significantly. Cities including New York, San Francisco, and Santa Monica have implemented strict STR regulations that limit or effectively prohibit whole-property short-term rentals. Many other cities are moving in the same direction. Before investing in an STR strategy, verify current local ordinances, check whether permits are required, and assess the regulatory trend in your market — not just current rules.
Can I switch between STR and LTR if one stops working?
Yes, with some transition friction. Converting STR to LTR requires de-furnishing or finding a furnished tenant, shifting insurance policies, and adjusting management approach. Going the other direction requires furnishing investment, platform setup, and a ramp-up period before bookings stabilize. The optionality is real — but it's not instant, and transition periods mean vacancy. Factor that into your decision if flexibility is a priority.
Free — no account required
Run Both Models Side by Side Before You Decide
The STR vs. LTR decision is market-specific, property-specific, and operator-specific. Adjust occupancy assumptions, management structure, and nightly rates to find exactly where the crossover point is for your specific situation — before you furnish a bedroom or sign a lease.